Two Capuchins, Two Churches, & Turning to Christ

Curious about the two paths American Catholicism could take? Tom Roberts of National Catholic Reporter uses two high-ranking Capuchins, Cardinal Sean O’Malley of Boston and Archbishop Charles Chaput of Philadelphia, as models for these two churches, so to speak. The key quotes about each man, in my opinion, are below.

On O’Malley:

Archbishop O’Malley mowing a lawn

“His emphasis throughout his life has been on the poor and those on the margins, and he recalled sheltering people in the wake of riots that broke out in Washington, where he was then living, following the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr. in 1968. O’Malley followed that by joining the Poor People’s March, ‘sleeping in a tent city’ and watching protestors get tear-gassed.

“He was a prison chaplain and ministered to immigrants and refugees while staying at Washington’s Centro Catolico Hispano during the 1970s and ’80s…He organized a rent strike among poor tenants until improvements were made to their property.”

On Chaput:

Archbishop Chaput

“Chaput’s is a rather gloomy view of the church and the world…His language is littered with phrases that are derisive of everyone else…When asked if he sees even a little hope, he replied, ‘I see some lights, but they’re not many and they’re small.’

“Everything, it seems, is someone else’s fault, and Chaput appears to hover above the fray, with both the accusatory analysis and all the answers. Not once did he even hint that perhaps Catholics in places like Philadelphia were leaving in droves because church leaders, especially bishops, deeply and horribly betrayed them in ways that would put the most relativistic, hedonistic secularist to shame. Perhaps they were leaving because they can’t stand to be in an institution led by men who had so little regard for their children that they would tolerate the rape and molestation of those children for decades without saying anything to anyone.”

Roberts concludes with some rhetorical questions, but it is obvious the answers. Americans are faced with the choice between a conservative pessimist who relishes conflict and thrives off condemnation or a more moderate leader who lives out the Gospel of the marginalized (i.e, the Gospel) through dynamism and love. Is there even a decision about where our Church needs to go?

Luckily, it seems Pope Francis seems to get it and perhaps, if we’re lucky, the hyper-partisanship of the US bishops I’ve written about before might cede to a more pastoral leadership we can all embrace. And if Archbishop Chaput needs a little more light and hope in the meantime, I suggest he turn to the blinding light of Christ that can set the world aflame.



1 Comment

Filed under Uncategorized

One response to “Two Capuchins, Two Churches, & Turning to Christ

  1. David

    I may have a different perspective to shed light on the two bishops you, (and Mr. Roberts) critique:

    I have roots in Boston, and was present at the Columbine shooting.

    Chaput was the Denver Bishop at that time. I was there ministering to the students that entire week, and was present at a Mass for four dead children from that shooting. That entire week I watched and listened as Bishop Chaput in a quiet voice and without fanfare compassionately honored the dead and offered words of solace to their families, honored the first responders, opened the doors of the local parishes and kept them operating 24/7, and essentially laid the resources of the Church at the service of the entire town. And trust me the town noticed.

    I have also seen Archbishop O’Malley arrive to an event in a caravan of three black SUVs, and hurry into a building in a detached and businesslike manner.

    I would guess that these two images would not match up well with the ones you’ve used in your essay. Just a caution about judging a book by its cover – I happen to think that both men are outstanding shepherds, (and whether calling a spade a spade equals pessimism is another discussion.) I’ll happily listen to and follow both of them. But as far as the false dichotomy that’s been set up, perhaps Jesus already gave his opinion on this when he called – and gave authority to – both fishermen and tax collectors.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s